Uplink guide

Living Post voting: how challenge results are decided

A Living Post moves from open to join, to entries, to voting, to result. Only signed-in members can vote, each account gets one vote per challenge, and the tally stays hidden until voting closes. Organizers can also name judges, and the rules say how ties are settled.

By Play 2 Earn Sports team · Last updated

Every Uplink challenge is a Living Post: a post that changes as the challenge moves along. It opens for players to join, collects video or photo entries, opens for voting and finally shows the result. This guide explains each phase, who can vote, why the tally stays hidden, how judges fit in, and how to handle ties so every result feels fair to players and families.

On this page
  1. The four phases of a Living Post
  2. Who can vote
  3. Why the tally stays hidden
  4. Judges versus member votes
  5. Ties
  6. Set up voting on a challenge in 6 steps
  7. Making results feel fair
  8. Moderation during voting
  9. Questions

The four phases of a Living Post

An organizer, who can be a coach, a club or a player, posts the challenge. From there it moves through four phases:

The four phases of a Living Post
PhaseWhat happensWho acts
Open to join The challenge and its rules are visible; players join Players
Entries Players submit a video or photo entry before the deadline Players
Voting Members vote, judges score, or both Members and judges
Result The tally is revealed and the result is posted Organizer

The same post carries the whole story, so the team does not have to hunt through separate messages for the rules, the entries and the winner.

Who can vote

Voting is limited to signed-in members. Each account gets one vote per challenge. This keeps voting tied to real members rather than anyone who happens to see a link, and it stops one person from voting over and over.

Who counts as a member depends on the post's visibility. A club-only challenge is seen by club members, and a private challenge only by the group it was shared with.

Why the tally stays hidden

The vote count stays hidden until voting closes. Hidden tallies matter for a few reasons:

  • Early entries do not snowball just because they were first.
  • Players are less tempted to lobby for votes when they cannot see the gap.
  • Younger players are spared watching a live count while voting is open.
  • The result feels like a reveal, which is part of the fun.

Judges versus member votes

Organizers can name judges for a challenge. Judges and member votes suit different kinds of challenges.

  • Judges are best for technique, form and accuracy, where a trained eye matters. Choose adults who know the skill and give them a clear scoring rule.
  • Member votes suit fun, creative or trick challenges, where the team's favorite is a fair winner.
  • Both can work for bigger club challenges. If you combine them, say in the rules how, for example "judges pick three finalists, members vote for the winner".

Whatever you choose, write it into the rules before the challenge opens, so nobody feels the method changed after they entered.

Ties

Ties are the organizer's call, and the call should be stated in the rules up front. Common tiebreaks:

  • A judges' decision between the tied entries.
  • A shared win.
  • The earlier entry wins.
  • A short tiebreak round with a fresh attempt.

A tiebreak written in advance avoids arguments after the result.

Set up voting on a challenge in 6 steps

  1. Write the rules and the method

    Describe the task, what counts and what voids an attempt, then say whether judges, members or both decide, and how ties are settled.

  2. Choose the visibility

    Pick public, club-only or private. This decides which members see the challenge and can vote. Club-only suits most youth teams.

  3. Name the judges

    If you use judges, add them and tell them the scoring rule and the date they need to finish.

  4. Set the phase dates

    Give a closing date for entries and a closing date for voting. A week for entries and three days for voting suits most teams.

  5. Remind members to vote

    Mention voting at practice or in your team chat. Remind members they get one vote and the count stays hidden until the end.

  6. Post the result

    When voting closes, the tally is revealed. Post the result, thank everyone who entered and call out effort or improvement as well as the winner.

Making results feel fair

Voting is only part of fairness. A few habits help players accept the result:

  • Keep entries to the rules; void entries that break them, and say why politely.
  • Avoid challenges where older or bigger players always win; use age groups.
  • Rotate challenge types so different players have a chance to shine.
  • Recognize more than one entry when you post the result.

Moderation during voting

Moderators can restrict or remove posts. If an entry breaks the rules or shows something it should not, such as a child's location or a school logo, restrict or remove it and let the player and their guardian know. See safe sharing for youth teams.

Questions

Only signed-in members can vote, and the post's visibility decides who sees it. A club-only challenge is visible to club members.

Each account has one vote per challenge. Plan your vote before you cast it; the organizer's rules explain anything specific to that challenge.

The tally stays hidden until voting closes, then the result is posted on the same Living Post.

That depends on the rules the organizer set before the challenge opened. State how judges and member votes combine, and how ties are broken, in the rules.

Keep reading

Related pages