Why do hockey players fight?

Players fight to retaliate, send a message, protect teammates or change momentum, but organized hockey punishes it. Hockey Canada says minor hockey does not permit fighting, and a fight brings a major penalty, game misconduct and suspension. Leagues also review repeat offenders.

Adult ice hockey players contesting a puck

Last updated

  • Fighting is banned in minor hockey.
  • Repeated fights can bring a hearing or expulsion.
  • Coaches teach legal body contact instead.

What Hockey Canada counts as a fight

Hockey Canada's rulebook does not leave the term to guesswork. Rule 7.10 says a fight has occurred when at least one player punches or attempts to punch an opponent repeatedly, or when two players wrestle in a way that makes it hard for the linespersons to step in and separate them. An altercation is a narrower idea: at least two players, with at least one of them penalized.

The penalty ladder is blunt. A minor penalty may not be assessed for fighting. The player who fights an opposing player gets a major penalty and a game misconduct. Anyone who joins in, acts as a peacemaker, or takes part in a secondary fight during the same stoppage also receives a game misconduct.

The suspension a Canadian minor hockey fight carries

Hockey Canada states plainly that it does not permit fighting in minor hockey. Beyond the major and game misconduct on the scoresheet, the parents' FAQ lists an automatic one-game suspension for a fighting major, and two games if the fight happens in the last 10 minutes of play.

The same FAQ warns that repeat offenders may face an indefinite suspension, a formal disciplinary hearing, or expulsion from the league, and that Hockey Canada members can add further penalties at their discretion. That is why a single fight can affect more than the player who threw the punch.

Why referees look for the instigator, not just the punch

The instigator rule explains the behaviour that starts most fights. An instigator is the player who, by demeanour or actions, causes the fight: throwing or attempting the first punch, issuing a verbal threat, removing gloves first, travelling across the ice to an altercation, or punching an opponent who has said no. Retaliation for a legal or illegal action is on the same list.

An aggressor is different: the player who keeps throwing punches or grappling after the opponent can no longer defend, with the intent to intimidate or punish. Instigator and aggressor each add a minor penalty, but not a major, match, misconduct or game misconduct. Referees are given wide latitude because the rule asks them to separate who started a fight from who continued it.

The rulebook also protects the player who does not fight back. If a player makes no attempt to retaliate other than to protect or defend themselves, and the referee judges that they did not engage, only the opponent gets the major and game misconduct. The defending player may receive a minor for roughing or perhaps no penalty at all.

Canada vs the US: different books, same direction

In the United States, USA Hockey's Rule 615(d) gives a game misconduct to any player or goaltender who is first to intervene in an altercation already in progress, on top of any other penalty from the incident. USA Hockey says the spirit and intent of that rule is to stop one-on-one altercations from turning into multi-player brawls.

High school hockey in the US follows a different book again. The NFHS points of emphasis lists fighting among the plays that are illegal and must be eliminated, next to hits to the head and blindside hits. The NHL keeps a separate Rule 46 for fighting, which is why a professional game and a minor hockey game can look so different.

Frequently asked questions

Can one fight end a player's season in Canada?

It can lead there. A fighting major means an automatic one-game ban, and two games when the fight lands in the final 10 minutes. A repeat offender can be suspended indefinitely, called to a disciplinary hearing, or expelled, and Hockey Canada members may add penalties on top.

Does the player who only defends themselves get suspended?

Not as a fighter. Under Hockey Canada's reading of Rule 7.10, when a player makes no attempt to retaliate beyond protecting or defending themselves and the referee decides they did not engage, only the opponent is assessed the major and game misconduct. The defending player may get a roughing minor or no penalty.

What is the third-man-in rule in USA Hockey?

USA Hockey Rule 615(d) gives a game misconduct to the first player or goaltender who intervenes in an altercation already under way, in addition to any other penalty from the incident. USA Hockey says the rule exists to keep a one-on-one altercation from becoming a multi-player brawl.

Is fighting legal in the NHL if minor hockey bans it?

The NHL publishes its own Rule 46 for fighting, separate from the minor hockey rulebooks. That is why a professional game handles a fight under a different code from a Hockey Canada or USA Hockey youth game. A player in minor hockey is still governed by the youth book, whatever the NHL does.

Sources

  1. hockeycanada.ca
  2. Hockey Canada - Rule 7.10 Fighting
  3. Hockey Canada - Rule 7.11 Instigator & Aggressor
  4. USA Hockey - Altercation Rule 615(d)
  5. NFHS - Ice Hockey Points of Emphasis
  6. NHL - Video Rulebook: Fighting
Open Next Play