Can a baseball game end in a tie?
Under MLB rules, a tied game does not end as a tie: it goes to extra innings and continues until one team leads. If weather stops a regulation game while tied, it becomes a suspended game completed later. Youth leagues may have their own tie rules.
Last updated
- Extra innings continue until a winner emerges.
- Weather can suspend a tied regulation game.
- Suspended games resume from the stopping point.
- Check youth league rules for time-limit ties.
Why a Major League game keeps going
MLB does not stop at a tie after nine innings. Once both teams have made 27 outs, a tied game goes to extra innings. From there it continues until the home team takes the lead at any point, or the visiting team takes the lead and the home team then makes three outs without tying the game or going ahead.
The regulation-game definition matters when weather arrives. If a game is called early, the result is final when the home team is leading. When the home team is trailing, the result is final only if the game is not in the middle of an inning in which the visiting team has taken the lead. A regulation game stopped while tied becomes a suspended game, completed later from the point of termination.
When a US high school game can be a tie
The National Federation of State High School Associations writes a separate rulebook. Under NFHS Rule 4-2-2, any game tied at the end of four and a half innings, or after at least five full innings, when it is called is a tie game, unless the state association has adopted its own game-ending procedure. That leaves room for state-by-state differences.
A tie is not treated like a win or a loss in the standings. NFHS rules count the batting and fielding records from the game, but do not count the game itself when computing won-lost percentages. Some states also adopt a tiebreaker: the NFHS suggested option places the player scheduled to bat last in that half inning on second base to start each extra half inning.
Canada: no tie games at a championship
The Western Canada Baseball Association posts a different answer for its championship events. Its rules say all games are seven innings, or six and a half innings if the home team is winning, and that there are no tie games. In round-robin play, a tie is settled with the extra-inning procedure in Baseball Canada Rule 5.10.
Medal play is treated differently: Rule 5.10 does not apply to semifinal or medal-round games. If the gold-medal game is called because of rain or darkness, five innings make it a complete game. Tiebreaker games are scheduled for three innings, and the extra-inning procedure begins in the fourth inning.
What Little League does with a tied time-limit game
Little League's Rule 4.00 guidance answers the time-limit question directly. If a game is suspended because the time limit is reached and the score is tied, the game is resumed from the point where it was halted. The suspended game is treated as the same game, so the pitcher of record may pitch in the resumed game if that pitcher is still eligible.
The practical effect is that the game does not restart from the first inning; play returns to the exact situation where it stopped, with the same pitcher of record if that pitcher is still eligible.
Frequently asked questions
Can a Major League game end in a tie?
No. A tied MLB game after nine innings goes to extra innings and continues until the home team leads, or the visiting team leads and the home team makes three outs. If weather stops a regulation game while the score is tied, the game is suspended and finished later.
Can a high school baseball game in the US end in a tie?
Yes, in some circumstances. NFHS rules make a game a tie if it is called at the end of four and a half innings or after at least five full innings while tied, unless the state association has adopted a different ending procedure. The tie counts in batting and fielding records but not in won-lost percentages.
Does a Canadian championship allow a tie game?
Not under the Western Canada Baseball Association rules. Round-robin ties are settled with the extra-inning procedure in Baseball Canada Rule 5.10, and medal games use a different rule. A gold-medal game stopped by rain or darkness becomes official after five innings.
How is a suspended Little League game restarted?
It resumes from the exact point where it stopped. Little League says the suspended game is the same game, so the pitcher of record can keep pitching if eligible, and the game does not begin again from the first inning.
Why would a league put a runner on second base in extra innings?
It is a tiebreaker option, not a universal rule. The NFHS suggests starting each extra half inning with the player who was scheduled to bat last in that half inning placed on second base. A state association has to adopt the procedure before it is used.
Sources
Baseball questions · Find a baseball team
Running a club or league? See club management software, moving off LeagueApps, free round robin generator, or league schedule maker.
Open Next Play