Switching gym software feels risky because your members, their payments and their class history all live in the old system. Most problems come from a few predictable gaps: a partial export, credits that do not carry over, card details that cannot move, and members who only find out on the day. A good switch is a short project with an owner, a date and a test. The checklist above walks through every step; tick each item and copy the list to share with staff. The sections below explain why each step matters and what to look for.
On this page
What data to export
Ask your current vendor for exports in CSV or spreadsheet format and check them before you give notice. You want:
| Data | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Member profiles | Names, contacts, start dates and status are the base of everything |
| Plans and prices | Members on older prices expect to keep them |
| Credits and pack balances | Lost credits are the most common complaint after a switch |
| Bookings and recurring bookings | Members expect their regular slot to still be theirs |
| Waivers and notes | Needed for safety and for your insurer |
| Attendance history | Useful for churn and retention numbers later |
| Payment references | Needed to move subscriptions without asking for new cards |
Card numbers themselves usually sit with your payment processor, not your gym software. If you already use Stripe, your subscriptions can often stay there and only the software layer changes. If your old system used its own processor, ask both sides how card data is transferred securely, since processors have their own migration processes and you should never handle raw card numbers yourself.
Switch gym software in 6 steps
-
Read the contract
Find the notice period, renewal date and any export terms. Time your switch so you are not paying two systems longer than needed.
-
Export and check
Download every export, then open each file and compare totals with the old dashboard: active members, credits outstanding, future bookings.
-
Test a small batch
Import 20 to 50 members, including awkward cases like frozen accounts and family plans. Fix the mapping until the test matches.
-
Move billing
Confirm each member's next charge date, run a staff test charge, and avoid a date where members could be billed twice or not at all.
-
Tell members early
Send a clear message a week before: what changes, what stays the same, and what they need to do, ideally nothing beyond downloading an app.
-
Go live and watch
Switch on the date, keep the old system read-only for one billing cycle, and check the first billing run and first week of check-ins.
Worked example: a 300-member switch
Example inputs only. A gym with 300 active members, 60 class-pack holders and 40 recurring bookings plans its switch for the 3rd of the month, two days after its main billing run. The export shows 300 members, 412 unused credits and 40 recurring slots. After the test import of 40 members, the owner finds frozen members imported as active, fixes the status mapping, and re-runs. The full import then matches all three totals. Members get an email and a chat message on the 26th, staff practise check-in on the 2nd, and the old system stays read-only until the 5th of the following month. The numbers are your inputs, not a forecast; the point is to compare totals at every stage.
Mistakes to avoid
- Cancelling the old system before you have a verified export.
- Switching mid-cycle, which can double-charge or skip members.
- Ignoring credits and legacy prices, which members notice first.
- Telling members on the day instead of a week ahead.
- Deleting the old account before the first full billing run on the new one.
Where P2ES Gym fits
P2ES Gym imports your member list, plans and class schedule, and connects to your own Stripe account so dues go to you. Each member who joins is linked to a free P2ES athlete profile with bookings, check-ins and Team Chat in one place. If you want to compare what you pay today, use the switch-cost pages such as the Mindbody alternative or the Glofox alternative.
US$149/month for the gym. Members are free. Member dues go straight to your gym through your own Stripe account; Stripe's standard processing fees apply and are paid by the gym. P2ES takes no cut.
Questions
For a single-location gym, plan for two to four weeks from the first export to going live, mostly spent checking data and waiting for the right billing date. The import itself is usually quick. Larger gyms, multi-site groups and gyms changing payment processors at the same time should allow more time for testing and member communication.
It depends on where the cards are stored. If your subscriptions already run through your own Stripe account and the new software connects to that same account, members often do not need to re-enter anything. If the old system used its own processor, ask both companies about their secure card migration process before you set a date.
Most gym software offers a member export, but the detail varies. Ask your vendor for members, plans, credits, bookings, attendance and payment references, and check whether some exports need a support request. Do this before giving notice, so you know exactly what you will get.
Credits move only if you export each member's balance and import it into the new system. Check total outstanding credits before and after the import. If expiry dates differ between systems, decide in advance whether to honour the old dates and tell members clearly.
Pick a date just after your main billing run and outside your busiest season, so there is time to fix problems before the next charge. Avoid switching during a big promotion or challenge. Give members at least a week of notice and train staff on the new check-in flow first.
Keep the old system read-only rather than running both live. Running two live systems risks double bookings and double charges. A read-only old account lets you look up history and resolve questions for one billing cycle, then download a final archive and close it.
