Choosing a gym

How do I choose a gym?

Choose a gym by deciding what matters most to you, then comparing a short list on those criteria. Location and opening hours usually matter most because they decide whether you will actually go. Then weigh price, equipment, classes, cleanliness and atmosphere, take a tour or trial at the time you would train, and read the contract before joining.

Bright scorecard comparing three gyms with star ratings for location, price and equipment

Last reviewed

Try it: free tool

General fitness information, not medical advice. Everything runs in your browser; nothing is saved unless you sign in.

The best gym for you is the one you will keep going to. A gym with excellent equipment is of little use if it is a 40-minute drive, packed at the only time you can train, or tied to a contract that does not suit you. Choosing well comes down to knowing your priorities, visiting a short list of options at the right time of day, and reading the terms before you sign. The scorer above lets you rate up to three gyms on seven criteria, with your own weights, so the decision reflects what matters to you. General fitness information, not medical advice.

On this page
  1. Start with your priorities
  2. The seven criteria in the scorer
  3. How to use the gym scorer above
  4. Worked example
  5. What to do on a tour or trial
  6. What to ask about the contract
  7. Choosing as a beginner
  8. Log it in your free athlete profile
  9. Questions

Start with your priorities

Before visiting anywhere, answer these questions:

  1. When will you train? Early morning, lunch, evening, weekends?
  2. Where will you come from? Home, work, or on the way between them?
  3. What will you do there? Free weights, machines, classes, swimming, cardio, sport-specific training?
  4. What is your budget? Include joining fees and annual fees, not just the monthly price.
  5. What atmosphere suits you? Quiet and focused, social, beginner-friendly, performance-focused?

The seven criteria in the scorer

The seven criteria in the scorer
CriterionWhat to check
Location Travel time at the hour you would go; parking or transport
Hours Open at your training times, including weekends and holidays
Price Monthly fee, joining fee, annual fee, contract length
Equipment Enough racks, benches and dumbbells for your plan; condition
Classes Types, times, booking system, class sizes
Cleanliness Changing rooms, equipment wipes, ventilation
Atmosphere Friendliness, crowd at your time, staff availability

How to use the gym scorer above

  1. Enter up to three gyms.
  2. Rate each one from 1 to 5 on location, hours, price, equipment, classes, cleanliness and atmosphere.
  3. Set a weight for each criterion, so more important factors count more.
  4. Read the weighted scores to see which gym fits your priorities.

Worked example

Example inputs: someone who trains on weekday evenings and cares most about location and equipment. Weights: location 3, hours 2, price 2, equipment 3, classes 1, cleanliness 2, atmosphere 1 (total 14).

Worked example
Criterion (weight)Gym AGym BGym C
Location (3) 5 3 4
Hours (2) 4 5 4
Price (2) 3 4 5
Equipment (3) 4 5 2
Classes (1) 2 4 3
Cleanliness (2) 4 4 3
Atmosphere (1) 4 3 3

Weighted totals: Gym A = 15 + 8 + 6 + 12 + 2 + 8 + 4 = 55. Gym B = 9 + 10 + 8 + 15 + 4 + 8 + 3 = 57. Gym C = 12 + 8 + 10 + 6 + 3 + 6 + 3 = 48. Dividing by 14 gives averages of about 3.9, 4.1 and 3.4. In this example Gym B narrowly wins, but Gym A is close enough that a trial visit should decide it.

What to do on a tour or trial

  • Visit at the time you would actually train, not a quiet mid-afternoon if you go at 6 pm.
  • Count the squat racks or the equipment you rely on, and see how many are in use.
  • Look at changing rooms and showers.
  • Ask about inductions, beginner support and personal training.
  • Check how classes are booked, whether there is a waitlist, and how busy popular classes get.
  • Ask whether the gym has an app for bookings, check-in and your training history.

What to ask about the contract

  • Is there a minimum term, and how much notice is needed to cancel?
  • Is there a joining fee or annual fee, and when is it charged?
  • Can you freeze the membership for travel or injury?
  • Are there off-peak or student options?
  • Does the price include classes, or are they extra?

Get answers in writing, and read the terms before you pay.

Choosing as a beginner

Beginners often do best at a gym with friendly staff, a free induction, beginner classes and a calm area with machines. A smaller, quieter gym close to home can be a better start than a large one with more equipment you will not use yet. If you have a medical condition or injury, ask your doctor or a qualified professional what type of facility suits you.

Log it in your free athlete profile

Wherever you join, the free P2ES athlete profile keeps your workout log with you. If your gym uses P2ES, your classes, check-ins and trainer bookings appear on the same account, and your watch workouts can connect too. It is free for athletes.

Questions

Start with location and opening hours, because they decide how often you will go. Then check price including joining and annual fees, equipment for your plan, classes, cleanliness and atmosphere at your training time. Take a tour or trial and read the contract terms before joining.

A gym with a free induction, approachable staff, beginner classes and a calm machine area often suits beginners. Convenience matters most: a nearby gym you visit three times a week is better than a well-equipped one you rarely reach. Visit at your usual training time to see how busy and welcoming it feels.

Choose the location that fits the time you will train. If you train before work, near home may suit you; if you train at lunch or straight after work, near your workplace can be easier. Some people pick a gym on the route between them. Think about weekends too.

Ask about busy times, equipment availability, class booking and waitlists, induction or beginner support, cleaning routines, personal training, and the contract: minimum term, notice period, joining and annual fees, and freeze options. Ask to see the changing rooms and visit at your usual training time.

It can be, if it has what you need at the times you train. Compare yearly cost including joining and annual fees, and think about cost per visit based on how often you will go. A lower price is not good value if the gym is too busy or missing the equipment your plan needs.

Only if you are confident the gym suits you. Rolling monthly options or short trials give you time to check whether you use it regularly. If a long contract offers a lower price, read the cancellation terms carefully, including notice periods and fees, before signing.

General fitness information, not medical advice. Talk to a doctor or qualified professional before changing your training or diet, especially with a health condition, an injury, during pregnancy or under 18.

Keep reading

Related pages

Keep your results in one place

A free P2ES athlete profile keeps your workout log, results and classes together. General fitness information, not medical advice.